Is YouTube Killing Itself?

This article displays my dis-taste and my concerns about the future of YouTube.
By Flash Cake, Published: Mar 30, 2016 | | |
Average User Rating:
  1. upload_2016-3-30_14-14-53.png

    I’m sure some of you are aware of the controversy around YouTube’s algorithm. In case you don’t know, YouTube is publicising channels based on the frequency of uploads and the length of videos. Don’t quote me on this but the reasoning behind this is because the more videos you upload, the more YouTube can play ads on the videos and make more money. And that I can understand, complaining that a company wants money is like complaining that porn is too graphic.

    But the problem I have with the algorithm is that it means that there is no longer an even playing field for creators. The thing that got this thought ball rolling was 2 tweets. One from Shane Gill and the other from Gaijin Goombah.


    And let’s begin with the one about small channels. There are thousands of small channels that are around that have marketed themselves on having high production values and a good amount of effort put into them but YouTube isn’t paying people based on the best workers, it’s paying by the hardest workers. Those small channels can’t grow because they can’t upload quickly (due to the fact they aren’t doing YouTube full time) and if they change their shows to be lower effort then they lose some of their artistic integrity and don’t want that.

    Then we have the channels that are already established. We have the big channels that are staying afloat fine and will do for some time but there are not a lot of small channels that aren’t rising. And when you’re a small channel doing something that doesn’t get noticed, that’s a huge demoraliser.

    And this is the part that concerns me. What happens when the big channels start to go away? What if Game Grumps went their separate ways because they got big doing their own thing? What if TeamFourStar got destroyed by copyright? What if PewDiePie became a television host? If they all go, then there will be no-one to replace them because the algorithm won’t support it. And honestly, I won’t be at all surprised if YouTube in a couple years’ time becomes irrelevant. 10 years ago, Newgrounds was the place for video uploads. Now it’s YouTube. And who’s to say the next 10 years won’t be dominated by daily motion.

    The way that it’s gone recently is that there is only one "good" way for a channel to grow. Creating drama. If there are two YouTubers that attack each other online and it gets people buzzing, while it’s creativity a toxicity, it’s mutually beneficial for both channels. (h3h3 Productions and LeafyIsHere both got a jump in subscribers during the day of the mutual “RANT” videos). Then you have people like I Hate Everything who got huge drama under the Cool Cat shenanigans and then after getting through that, he had his entire channel deleted. While shitty at the time, I’m sure there’s a lot of people who wouldn’t mind going through exactly the same thing.

    (Below is the Social Blade graph for I Hate Everything's Channel)

    And I know all the publicity comes from shares on social media but I just want to give a contrast on that effect. About a month back I made a Game Theory parody that was very well received. Gaijin Goombah shared that video on his twitter and for a Tweet with 43 thousand followers, my video got maybe an extra 400 views and 20 new subscribers. So while sharing on social media helps, the only way to get anything significant is promoting directly from YouTube.

    When it comes to my small channel, over half of those subscribers came from a larger channel that I had previously set up. And you see this all over with channels like Game Grumps showcasing animations from a bunch of people because animators have the toughest time with the algorithm. Making short animations is time consuming enough but to make long cartoon on a frequent basis is not physically possible without Warner Brother size teams.

    And I’m sure some of you are thinking “Well what about Patreon”
    Yes, that’s fine for the middle of the road YouTubers. The people with 100K subs benefit heavily from patreon but a small channel doesn’t have the publicity to get funding from that.

    And there are channels that will help out other channels but the poor have to stand on the shoulders of giants if they ever want to see above the storm clouds.

    And let’s briefly go over the other thing that may kill YouTube, the copyright and fair use clause. Now people will tell you that there are ways to bump yourself up in search engines and I tried doing this. What I was told was if you put the name of the thing you’re talking about in the description of the video as well as title, it will help you up the ladder. So I did this to my channel but I did it to only 3 of my 11 videos at the time and checked the analytics later. The videos in question were a Megaman X review, A rant about bats in video games and a review of the original Terminator. And not a couple hours after changing the description, monetisation was claimed for Metro Goldwyn Meyer on my Terminator video. And I probably got lucky on that one. Who’s to say it couldn’t be a strike or the video was banned viewing in the US. And the whole #WTFU has blown over now but the problem has not gone away.

    Now, when it comes to videos, I’m not going to stop creating. Creating for me has been an addiction for most my life. I will never stop drawing, I will never stop writing and I will never stop producing videos but with such a revenue centric algorithm in place, those videos aren’t going to be published on YouTube
    No-one’s will.

    I don’t want YouTube to die because familiarity breed contempt but there is going to be a day in the not too distant future where someone will say “Do you remember YouTube” and the other person’s just going to reply “No”


    Share This Article

    About Author

    Flash Cake
    I'm a comedy YouTuber, taking apart the plot holes, inconsistencies and general weirdness among Video Games, Movies, TV Shows and Anime.


To make a comment simply sign up and become a member!
  1. Spunkly
    I think the big issue with the fair use policies and copyright strikes given out by "hollywood" is that YouTube is afraid to fight Hollywood and Hollywood is afraid that YouTube's creators are going to take over their industry. So the whole thing is this big circle of fear. YouTube needs to step in and say "what these creators are doing is legal and fair." Quite frankly, YouTube is allowing Hollywood and other big companies to take money from creators illegally and the creators have to sit back in their chair and watch it happen. Where's the incentive to make money when these corporations are taking half of it. I'm not saying that I or anyone else is doing YouTube to make money, but it's something we love doing and if we want to do it full time we need money for bills.

    I've heard that Twitch may start doing a video upload like YouTube just to counter attack YouTube's live streaming. If that is the case and does happen, I'll probably start paying more attention to Twitch instead of YouTube because Twitch actually cares about their creators. YouTube seems to be at a point where the big get bigger and the small are at a loss.

    I guess to me, the biggest issue on YouTube right now is fear and money. YouTube protects the bigger YouTubers such as Pewdiepie for example. Then they throw smaller channels under the bus because they don't make them enough money. YouTube is afraid of lawsuits. Because YouTube is afraid of lawsuits, they are allowing companies to get away with wrongfully stealing money from people rightfully creating content.

    That's my take on it. Correct me if I'm wrong anywhere, but from what I've been seeing, this is how a portion of the issue is.
  2. horrorkesh
    the problems i see is, anyone can claim on a video, people are claiming with no effort to fight anyone they will just let a claim fall off since the monitization is already taken from the most important time period of a video, unless the video becomes viral after the grace period, that and the algorithm for youtube favors the spammy click bait channels ergo watchmojo, its hard to get anywhere when youtube themselves recommends channels that are already well established, i get those channels make them the most money but boosting all the small channels would get them similar results.
      King Dippy likes this.
  3. King Dippy
    I'm like that too in terms of creating. I keep going even though I've gone nowhere in 2 (ish) years. I get practically no views without paid promotion, but I like what I do and still wanna get big doing it. I've always liked making stuff. Costumes, drawings, toys (a couple cardboard ones when I was young lol), etc. It's fun and it's a hobby that I can pour tons of creative energy into. And I get to have my own little shows going online.

    Now, for the longer videos thing, I'm assuming that's if they actually get watched, right? Please tell me Youtube isn't automatically promoting videos that are 40 minutes long just because. I mean, that's insane if they are. And I wouldn't doubt it at all. If they want more frequency though, then I'll be more than happy to spam lol. I love recording as much gameplay stuff as long as I have time to edit. No problems there.
    1. Flash Cake
      It's done on minutes watched. But it isn't balanced for short videos so if 1 Million people watched a 1 miute video and the same million watched half of a 10 minute video, YouTube would promote the 10 minute video 5 times more than the 1 minute video.
      Flash Cake, Apr 3, 2016
  4. Aurian MoonRose
    I won't say that Youtube is killing itself but there are a lot of problems not only with youtube, but fair usuage and the evoliving of socitey. Everything must evolve or it dies. Youtube is trying to keeps itself alive or thinks that it is withall the social media and TV going to strickly internet. However i will also say that you are correct that it is a shame that Youtube dores promote the Userss with more minutes to thier videos then those without and causing Creators to limit and cut down on what they do in there. videos just to try to keep up. YouTube was founded on us the users, and to share and do what we want to entertain, have fun, and just do what we may or may not ever be able to do ourselves. but yes i would not like Youtube to be a forggoten medium like so many before it, I have grown fond and accustom to where i am, but if i must move on and take my videos with i would. but i do feel how you feel on this subject :)
      Blake Howell likes this.
  5. Tyhd
    I agree YouTube may or may not die out in the next 10 years but that DailyMotion bit had me cracking up
      DefiantLynkGaming likes this.
    1. Blake Howell
      I don't think it will though
      Blake Howell, Apr 13, 2016
  6. Cay
    I don't know if it's dying but I'd say it's definitely changing, Like for everyone who's been around on youtube since like 09 you know how different it is since then and yeah it probably was better a few years back. But to be fair it's still probably better than any of the alternatives we have XD
    1. Tyhd
      Well that ultimatly depends on what content you make. For example filmmakers tend to post their content on Vimeo as the audience seems to be more mature and professional.
      Tyhd, Apr 5, 2016
  7. Skye Pie
    I've been a web developer before I was ever a YouTuber. The business model for growing a channel, SOLELY ON YOUTUBE, has been a wet dream. It's never been this way, despite what people might believe. The YouTube search algorithm has ALWAYS been horrible.

    There are several strategies to growing a YouTube channel. YouTube currently has over 2,000 channels with over 1 million subscribers. There have been people doing this for awhile now. And they know how to accrue views and subscribers. It's not a hard model to understand.
  8. FoxMcloud
    this is why my YouTube can't take off. ive been doing this since 2011. only 43 subs.
    1. DefiantLynkGaming
      I'm sorry to hear that, I'd love to check the channel out
      DefiantLynkGaming, Apr 11, 2016
  9. Endgam3r
    Another thing; there are people who exploit this algorithm and use clickbait thumbnails, titles and ever re-upload their old videos to get fresh views on them... Sinister people... people like...

    But that's another story for another day.

    A YouTuber made a couple videos explaining what exactly what's wrong with the YT, and the abuse of its' broken system and it ended up getting the CEO of YouTubes' attention.

    The CEO of YouTubes' Response

    If YouTube doesn't fix their algorithm, and stop the habitual breaking of community guidelines users will get fed up and be driven away and start uploading to a site like Vessel. I just hope hope YouTube fixes this broken system and the mess of an algorithm they have.
  10. Gearstv
    Honestly the only way to grow is to promote your youtube on a ton of websites and stream a lot and promote through there